A Rustic Scallion & Chive Panade

Name: Scallion & Chive Panade
Prep time: 45 min
Cook time: 120 min
Total time: 165 min
Ingredients: 12 ounces day-old artisan-style sourdough* (see headnotes); 1/2 cup extra-virgin olive oil; Salt; 2 pounds thinly sliced yellow onions; 7 cloves garlic, thinly sliced; 5 cups broth; 1 1/2 cups thinly sliced scallions; 8 ounces grated Gruyere cheese; 1/3 cup minced chives

The combination of simmering broth, Gruyere cheese, onions, garlic, chives, and sourdough combine into a decadent pot of winter magic.

Jump to Recipe

The panade recipe in The Zuni Cafe Cookbook came to my attention when a friend baked a beautiful double-version of it in an over-sized AGA dutch oven and served it at a dinner party years ago. It was the show-stopping centerpiece of a meal flanked by a beautiful winter green + chicory salad and gem-shaded glasses of wine. The combination of bubbling cubes of brothy bread and caramelized onions silkily merging with molten threads of cheese is knee-buckling. It’s the perfect example of a short list of the simplest ingredients coming together into something much more than then sum of their parts. My Favorite Panade Recipe
I’ve baked variations of this panade in the years since, and it never disappoints. It’s endlessly adaptable, meaning that you can add seasonal ingredients to suit your fancy. For example, in my case, I do a vegetarian version by switching up the broth, and I like my onions on the caramelized side of the spectrum. I’ll add whatever sautéed greens or roasted vegetables I have around. Judy also listed a range of ideas and variations in the cookbook, so if you have it (and you should!) be sure to have a glance at those for year-round inspiration. Her original had chard. I use lots of scallions in mine. In short, it’s one of those IYKYK recipes. Molly Wizenberg knew what was up way back in 2005 when she wrote about the Judy panade recipe here.

I’m going to dive in and answer a number of questions here that might pop up. The ingredient list for this panade couldn’t be simpler, but the devil is in the details and navigating personal preferences. Close-up of Panade in Cast-iron Casserole

What Kind of Bread for this Panade?

The short answer is a good, chewy artisan sourdough loaf. That said, I will also argue that a lot of this is personal preference. If you bake sourdough at home, by all means, use that. Either one of these choice will likely result in a nicely structured panade with nice distinction between some of the components. The bread choice is such a big deal in this recipe, each one will impact your end result immensely. I learned the hard way when I used a more commercial sourdough loaf to make the panade one night - much finer crumb, less/no chewiness, and I’m guessing it was 100% all-purpose flour. The resulting panade broke down too far, into an unstructured slump. You want the bread to put up a fight and hold a bit of tension. Not go to mush altogether. The best version I've made was with a loaf of day-old homemade sourdough made with wild rice in it.
Panade before baking

Crust or no Crust?

There are arguments for both. The panade here retained the crust on the bread cubes. But I’ve done crustless versions before. If you decide you love a super oozy, silky panade, go crustless. If you like your panade to have more structure, keep your crust. Or go 50/50! Preparing bread in large bowl before assembling panade.

What is the Best Broth for Panade?

We tend to use whatever good-tasting broth we have around or in the freezer (defrost). I love an herby broth for this scallion and chive version, but if you’re in a pinch grab a bouillon cube or two and go from there. Judy uses a chicken broth in her recipe (which doesn’t work for vegetarians), but I’ve had great results with mushroom broth, and corn broth along with roasted cherry tomatoes and goat cheese in the panade. I’ve even used spicy bean broth. Ingredients for panade arranged on countertop.

Can I use a Different Cheeses in this Panade?

You can! I call for Gruyere, but mention in the headnote that one of my favorite versions ended up being a blend of Gruyere, Parmesan, and Pecorino cheeses. I prefer slightly assertive cheeses for the panade, with at least a portion being a cheese that oozes when melted. For example, I wouldn’t reach for a mozzarella - too mild.
Sourdough bread for panade recipe.

Can I Make this Ahead of Time?

I often make the caramelized onions ahead of time. And then any other fillings that I might be able to pre-roast.

Soupy versus Dry-ish Panades

Again, this is personal preference. After you bake panade once or twice you’ll start to get a sense of what style you prefer. You can go the soup-is route by adding more broth. Or lean into more of a stuffing vibe with less broth. The recipe below aims to hit the mark where the panade is transitioning from a stuffing-like texture, into silkier magic, not-yet-in-soup territory.
My Favorite Panade Recipe
This recipe is a warming, hearty, winter warmer. It looks so rustic, but the silkiness down in the depths is what’s incredibly surprising. It’s the ultimate comfort dish that I hope you enjoy as much as I have over the years. Thanks to Jamie & Chanda & Bonni for our SF panade dinners, we miss them (and you) so much!

101 Cookbooks Membership

Premium Ad-Free membership includes:
-Ad-free content
-Print-friendly recipes
-Spice / Herb / Flower / Zest recipe collection PDF
-Weeknight Express recipe collection PDF
-Surprise bonuses throughout the year

browse more:

100+ Vegetarian Recipes

Scallion & Chive Panade

Join to PRINT

4.43 from 7 votes

The bread is important, and I go into more depth about it up above. Aside from getting your hands on a good, chewy loaf, you are going to need to decide whether to leave the crust on the sourdough or trim it. The former makes for a more rustic, structured panade, while crustless delivers something wonderfully molten - both version are fantastic. I call for Gruyere in the recipe to keep it simple, but one of my favorite versions of this panade was when I used a blend of equal parts Gruyere, Pecorino, and Parmesan cheeses (because that is what I happened to have on hand). Experiment!

Ingredients

12 ounces day-old artisan-style sourdough* (see headnotes)
1/2 cup extra-virgin olive oil
Salt
2 pounds thinly sliced yellow onions
7 cloves garlic, thinly sliced
5 cups broth
1 1/2 cups thinly sliced scallions
8 ounces grated Gruyere cheese
1/3 cup minced chives

Instructions

Cut or tear sourdough into rough 1-inch cubes. Set aside.

Caramelize the Onions:

You can prepare these a day or two in advance if you like. You’ll need a large, wide skillet, pan or pot. Place the onions in the pan, drizzle with 1/4 cup of the olive oil and set over medium-high heat. Stir well and season with a couple pinches of salt. They’ll cook down. Cook, stirring occasionally, until the onions start to color and begin to caramelize. I like to let them get super jammy, with lots of color, but not-at all burned. This can take about a half hour. Once you’re nearly done cooking the onions, reduce the heat to low and stir in the garlic. Cook until soft, 5-6 minutes. You should end up with 2 or 2 1/2 cups of cooked onions. Set aside.
Preheat the oven to 325F.
Place the bread cubes in a large bowl drizzle with 2 tablespoons of olive oil and 1/2 cup of the broth. Add 1 cup of the scallions and a few pinches of salt. Use your hands to toss and gently squeeze the bread cubes until evenly moist. Set aside.

To Build the Panade:

Choose an oven-proof 3-quart dutch oven or cast-iron pan or pot (12-cup capacity). See photos. Also note, you’re going to want a baking dish that can go from stove-top to oven. Assemble the panade in layers. Start with a layer of onions, followed by a loose layer of bread cubes, another layer of onions, and then a layer of grated cheese. Repeat: bread, onions, cheese, until you’ve reached the top of your pan. Aim for 2-3 layers of each component, packing down with a bit of pressure if needed. The top layer should have a some of everything. Add a finishing sprinkle of the remaining scallions and the chives. Drizzle with remaining 2 T. olive oil.
Bring the remaining 4 1/2 cups of broth to a simmer and taste for seasoning, it should taste good enough to drink. Pour it slowly over the panade, in doses, around the edges until it comes up nearly to the rim. Let it sit for a minute, allowing the bread to absorb the broth and add a bit more if needed.

Bake the Panade:

Set the panade over low heat and bring to a simmer. Look for bubbling at the edges and listen to know. Remove from heat. Cover with a layer of parchment paper, then loosely wrap the top and sides of the pan with foil, careful because the pan can be hot. Place another piece of foil or sheet pan on the rack below your panade in case it bubbles over. Bake for about an hour, before having a peek. Baking time will actually depend on your pan and oven - it can take longer. Take a peek, at this point the top should be getting a bit golden around the edges. If you’re not seeing any color, bake longer.
Uncover the panade, dial your oven to 375F, and bake until beautiful and golden on top, another 15-25 minutes. I sometimes give it a finishing kiss with the broiler if I’m not getting enough browning for my taste.
If you’re not ready to serve, re-cover the panade, reduce the oven back to 250F, and you can hold it there for a half an hour or so without issue. You can always test the panade. Basically you want to avoid dryness. Your panade should be silky and unctuous. If it seems a bit on the dry side you can add more hot broth a few tablespoons at a time and serve when ready.
Serve in pan after allowing to sit outside the oven for 10 minutes.

Notes

Serves 8.

Adapted from The Zuni Cafe Cookbook by Judy Rodgers published by W. W. Norton & Company (2002)

Serves

Prep Time

45 mins

Cook Time

2 hrs

Total Time

2 hrs 45 mins

Join to PRINT

nutrition info nutrition info